Annuities are insurance contracts bought by a person, known as the contract owner, that will pay the annuitant, the person who will receive the annuity, a periodic amount starting at a given date and continuing for the rest of the annuitant's life. Usually, but not necessarily, the contract owner and the annuitant are the same person. Although most annuities are for retirement, the payouts can start at any time. The duration when money is paid into an account is known as the accumulation period; the time that the annuitant receives the money is known as the annuity period. When the annuity period begins and the account starts paying the annuitant, then the account is said to be annuitized. The periodic payment is determined primarily by how much is in the account, how much it earns during the annuitant's life, and how long the annuitant is expected to live.
Note that these annuities are nonqualified annuities, meaning that they do not refer to the annuities paid by tax-qualified pension and profit-sharing plans, §403(b) plans and §457(b) plans offered to many employees.
The earnings in the account are tax-deferred; no taxes are due on earnings during the accumulation phase, but during the annuity period, earnings, but not principal, are taxed as ordinary income. The principal is not taxed because the premium is paid with after-tax dollars. During the annuity period, a certain percentage of the initial distributions is deemed a return of principal, so that percentage of the distribution is tax-free. After the principal has been reduced to 0, the entire portion of succeeding distributions will be subject to ordinary income taxes, even if the earnings were from capital gains. Many annuities provide a death benefit, but unlike the death benefit paid by life insurance, it is taxable to the beneficiaries.
Safety — Rating the Insurance Companies
Because annuities are not insured by the government, their safety depends on the claims-paying ability of the insurance company. Principal, earnings, and payouts can be lost if the insurance company defaults. This is particularly important considering that an annuity can last for decades. Consult A.M. Best, Moody's, and Standard and Poor's for ratings of insurance companies.
Fixed and Variable Annuities
There are different types of annuities that can be classified according to the variability of the periodic payment amount: fixed, variable, or a combination thereof.
A fixed annuity guarantees a specific payment starting at a specified date, and continuing every pay period, which can be monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually. The main advantage of a fixed annuity, unlike other investments, is that the payments are guaranteed for the life of the annuitant.
How can an insurance company guarantee payments to an individual without knowing beforehand how long that person will live? By spreading the risk over a large number of people. A payment for a fixed annuity depends, among other factors, on the life expectancy of the annuitant when payments begin. Some will live longer than expected, but others will die sooner. If the annuitant dies sooner, the insurance company keeps the rest of the principal; this will help pay for others who live longer.
A fixed annuity guarantees the principal, in that the payments will never be less than the total of the premiums paid minus some expenses and surrender charges. A specific interest rate is guaranteed for 1 to 3 years; afterwards, the insurer will generally offer another guaranteed interest rate for a specific time. Some annuity contracts have a bailout provision, that allows the policy owner to terminate the contract without surrender charges if the new guaranteed interest rate is less than the previous one by a certain amount, such as 2% less. To dissuade policyholders from canceling their contracts early, most annuity contracts assess a surrender charge that may start as high as 10% but then declines over the next few years. If the owner maintains a policy for a specified number of years, then no surrender charge will be assessed if the policy is canceled. This allows the insurer to invest the premiums into longer-term investments so that a higher rate of return can be earned.
The main risk with a fixed annuity is inflation risk. Inflation will continually lessen the amount of goods and services the fixed payment can buy. Although there are periods of economic deflation, most of the time, prices for goods and services continually increases, so this risk will increase the longer the annuitant lives.
A variable annuity has a variable payout that is contingent on the profitability of the investment portfolio on which the annuity is based, and thus, it can be a hedge against inflation. However, the selection of investments is limited to what is offered by the insurer, either proprietary funds or selected mutual funds. A variable annuity is like a tax-deferred mutual fund. Like a mutual fund, the maximum sales charge is 8.5% (for the 1st 12 years), and has breakpoints, letters of intent, and rights of accumulation. The premiums for a variable annuity are placed in a account that is separate from the general account of an insurance company, because the account is managed more aggressively for more income, but also with the attendant risk.
Variable annuities are an investment risk because the payout depends on the performance of a specific portfolio, and are therefore classified as securities by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). If the account doesn't perform well, the annuitant will receive reduced payments, or none at all.
There are 3 types of expenses associated with variable annuities. There is the mortality and expense risk charge, usually about 1.25% annually, that covers the guarantee that payments will be made for as long as the annuitant lives. There is also a fund expense incurred by the mutual funds that are selected for the annuity investment. A nominal administrative expense is also charged: either a flat fee of $25-$30 per year or a low percentage of the assets, typically around 0.15%.
The combination annuity combines fixed and variable annuities, guaranteeing the annuitant a specific amount, but also allowing the potential for more money from the variable annuity.
Because a variable annuity is a security and operates like a mutual fund, it is required to issue a prospectus to new investors that has most of the information that a prospectus of a mutual fund would have, in addition to a few features that are unique to variable annuities. One thing that cannot be done with variable annuities is to take dividends and capital gains as a cash distribution.
This is the guarantee that the annuitant will receive payments as long as he lives.
Expenses affect the separate account as much as a mutual fund. If expenses were allowed to rise over time, this could adversely affect the income that the annuitant was receiving. So annuity contracts usually guarantee that expenses will not exceed a stipulated amount, generally around 1%.
Should the annuitant die during the accumulation phase, then his estate is guaranteed to receive no less than what was paid in by the annuitant, minus some fees, which is limited by the expense guarantee.
During the accumulation phase, the money is still the contract owner's. He still has control of the money. If he was paying periodically, he can stop making payments, although this will reduce the annuitant's benefit. He can withdraw some or all the money — surrender the contract — but earnings will be taxed, and possibly be subject to a 10% tax penalty for early withdrawal. The insurance company will also assess a surrender charge that typically decreases the longer the contract is in force.
Not every annuity assesses a surrender charge, but some that do also provide free withdrawals for up to a certain percentage of the account value, typically 10%, per year. They may also provide waivers, where all or part of the money can be withdrawn without a surrender charge, if the contract owner has an urgent need for the money, such as extended hospitalization, a terminal illness, or becomes unemployed.
However, when the annuity period begins, the contract owner loses control of the account.
There are several ways to pay the premiums for the annuity.
Single Payment Immediate
Give the insurance company a single payment, then begin receiving payouts, which will be on the next payment date. Note that this could be as long as 1 year for the first payment, if the contract specifies yearly payments. This would be suitable for a soon-to-retire individual with a lump sum of money.
Single Payment Deferred
Same as above, but the payout is deferred, allowing the money to build over the years. Many lotteries use this method to pay winners, and sometimes professional athletes receive such a annuity paid for by the employer as a form of future compensation.
Periodic Payment Deferred Annuity
Premiums are paid monthly, quarterly, or annually. The amount can be fixed or variable. There are 2 forms of periodic payment, the level premium and the flexible premium.
The level premium is a fixed premium paid during the accumulation period. The level premium is determined by the annuitant's age and sex, the assumed interest rate, income amount and payment guarantee, and expenses, and obviously for periodic payments, how long the contract holder pays the premium. The more premiums paid, the lower the premium.
Because an annuity is paid for the annuitant's lifetime, life expectancy is an obvious factor to consider when calculating premiums, which, in turn, will depend on the annuitant's age at the start of the annuity period and sex, because women generally live longer than men. Some states, however, do not allow the premium to be contingent upon sex; in these states the sex of the annuitant won't matter. Another factor extending the time of the annuity period, for which premiums will be higher, is when a specific time period for payouts is guaranteed, or it is a joint-and-survivor annuity, which will likely increase the length of the annuity period.
The premium will obviously depend on:
- assumed interest rate (AIR), which is the amount the account is assumed to earn in interest;
- income amount, which is what the contract holder wants the annuitant to receive periodically; and
A higher assumed interest rate and lower expenses will lower the premium for a given income level, and vice versa.
The flexible premium can vary between a minimum and a maximum amount, specified in the contract, which the contract owner can pay during the accumulation period, which would be good for someone whose income varies considerably. However, the value of the annuity cannot be determined until the final payment, because there is no way to determine how much will be in the account when it is annuitized, although an average premium can be projected.
How Annuity Payments are Calculated
Fixed annuity payments are determined by insurance company annuity tables that give the first payment value per $1,000, which depends on the age and sex of the annuitant, the payout options chosen, and deductions for expenses. Thus, if an annuitant has $100,000 in his account, and the value is $5 per $1,000, then the first payment will be $500. For a fixed annuity, this will be the value of all subsequent payments.
Variable Annuity Accumulation Units and Annuity Units
During the accumulation period, the variable annuity contract owner's interest in the separate account is measured by accumulation units. Accumulation units track the shares of a variable annuity in the separate account, which is invested more aggressively for greater income. The number of accumulation units in the account is proportionate to the amount of money invested. These accumulation units are simply an accounting method of measuring the contract owner's interest in the separate account.
The accumulation unit, which is calculated like the net asset value (NAV) of a mutual fund, is equal to the total value of all securities held in the separate account divided by the number of accumulation units.
|Accumulation Unit||=||Total Value in Separate Account |
Number of Accumulation Units
The number of accumulation units that can be purchased is the net payment, which is the premium payment after sales charges are taken out, divided by the market value of the accumulation unit, which is determined by the NAV at the next close of a market day (the forward pricing rule):
|Number of Accumulation Units |
Per Premium Payment
|=||Premium – Sales Charges |
Market Value of
Thus, the contract holder's interest in the separate account at any given time is the number of accumulation units times the value of 1 accumulation unit.
For instance, before retirement, the number of accumulation units that are purchased each month will vary, depending on stock prices. For instance, assume that the accumulation unit is initially valued at $1, and the annuitant makes a monthly premium payment of $100. So during the 1st month, 100 units are purchased. If referenced stock prices rise in the 2nd month, so that the accumulation unit rises to $1.05, then only 95 accumulation units can be purchased for $100. If during the next month, the accumulation unit declines to $.95, then 105 accumulation units can be purchased, etc.
Annuitization is when the contract converts from the pay-in phase to the pay-out phase — the accumulation period ends and the annuity period begins. At this time, the annuitant selects a settlement option. Then the accumulation units are converted to a fixed number of annuity units according to a formula — the number of annuity units will never change. What varies is the value of each annuity unit, which will depend on the value of the portfolio in the separate account. When the performance of the separate account changes, the value of each annuity unit changes, and therefore the payment — which is calculated by multiplying the number of annuity units times the value of one unit — to the annuitant changes:
Variable Annuity Payment = Number of Annuity Units × Value of 1 Annuity Unit
Variable annuity contracts specify how often the payout can be changed: monthly, quarterly, semi-annually, or annually.
The calculation for the first payment of a variable annuity is the same as for the fixed annuity, but the dollar amount is converted to an equivalent of annuity units. For a variable annuity, the number of annuity units is calculated by dividing the first payment by the current value of an annuity unit:
|Number of Annuity Units||=||1st Payment |
Market Value of 1 Annuity Unit
This will yield a number that will not change during the annuity period; what changes is the value of the annuity unit. Thus, the annuitant's payment is equal to the number of annuity units times the value of each unit. So if $500 is the first payment, and $5 is the value of each annuity unit, then the annuitant has an interest in 100 units, which will not change. The value of the annuity unit, and therefore the payment to the annuitant, will rise and fall, depending on the value of the annuity unit, which in turn, will depend on the performance of the separate account.
So if an annuitant has 10,000 accumulation units at retirement, and the accumulation units are converted into 100 annuity units, then assuming that each annuity unit is valued at $10 in the 1st month, then the annuitant will receive $1000 for that month. If, in the 2nd month, the annuity unit increases to $10.50, then the monthly income will increase to $1050. On the other hand, a decline to $9.50 causes the monthly income to decline to $950.
A settlement option, which is selected when the annuity period begins, determines how the annuity will be paid, and what will happen when the annuitant dies.
For both fixed and variable annuities, under the most common settlement options, the annuitant is guaranteed to receive a payment for life — fixed annuities guarantee a specific amount, variable annuities do not.
Insurance companies can do this because the annuitant, through contract, depending on the settlement option, gives up the right to the principal once payments begin. If the annuitant dies earlier than expected, the insurance company keeps the rest of the principal; but if the individual lives longer than his life expectancy, then the insurance company must continue paying, even though the principal is depleted. The insurance company spreads the risk over many individuals — the principal left over from those who died earlier than expected helps the insurance company continue payments to those who are living longer.
This option has the highest payout for the amount of money invested. If the annuitant lives longer than expectant, then he gets more than he paid in, but if he dies earlier, then the insurance company keeps the balance of the principal.
Refund Life Annuity
This annuity guarantees that it will pay at least what the contract owner paid in premiums. If the annuitant dies before getting this amount, then the annuitant's beneficiary will get the remainder either as cash or as installment payments.
Life Annuity with Period Certain
With this option, the annuitant or his beneficiary is guaranteed to receive payments for at least a specified time, such as 10 years. If the annuitant dies before then, his beneficiary receives the payments for the duration of the term, but if the annuitant lives longer than expected, he still continues to receive payments until he dies, but once the term has elapsed, no payment will go to the beneficiary after the annuitant dies. Because of the guarantee, this payout is less than straight life for the same account.
Temporary Annuity Certain
Temporary annuity certain guarantees that payments will be made for a given number of years, usually 10, 15, or 20 years. After that, the payment stops, even if the annuitant lives longer. If the annuitant dies before the period elapses, then his beneficiary receives the remaining payments.
Joint and Survivor Annuity
Typically for husband and wife, when the annuitant dies, a specific percentage is paid to the other spouse until her death. Although the continued payment can be 100%, it is frequently less, because the surviving spouse will have lower living expenses, and therefore doesn't need the entire amount. The annuitant chooses the percentage out of choices provided by the insurance company, when the contract is signed. Naturally, a higher percentage lowers payouts to the primary annuitant.
The annuitant receives the earnings of the principal, but the principal is left intact. When the annuitant dies, the principal goes to the contract owner's beneficiary.
A lump sum payout gives the annuitant all the principal plus earnings at one time. However, taxes will then be due on the earnings of the principal, which will be taxed as ordinary income.
If the annuitant took monthly payments, only part of each payment, as determined by an IRS formula, would be taxable.
Installments of Designated Amounts
A specific amount is paid out until the account is exhausted. Obviously this settlement option, the lump sum option, and the temporary annuity certain option do not provide a lifetime of payments.
An annuity can be taken as a lump sum or as periodic payments. However, if taken as a lump sum, the money available will be different than if periodic payments were chosen under another settlement option. A two-tiered annuity has different values for distribution, depending on whether it is taken as a lump sum before annuitization, or is issued as periodic payments.
Tax-Deferred Annuity (TDA) or Tax-Sheltered Annuity (TSA)
Teachers and other employees of non-profit or tax-exempt organizations can benefit from tax-deferred annuities, sometimes referred to by the code section of the Internal Revenue Code that confers this benefit: sections 403(b) and 501(c)(3). This contrasts with the regular investor who must use after-tax dollars.
This is a salary reduction program — the money is invested before it is taxed. These annuities are available to all employees of qualified organizations, whether they are full- or part-time, but the program only applies to their earnings from the qualified organization. No other wages can be included. All earnings on the account grow tax-deferred. However, during the payout, all the money is taxed as ordinary income, whereas the ordinary investor only must pay taxes on any gains of the account, not on the principal.
Retirement Income Annuities
A retirement income annuity is a deferred annuity with a decreasing term life insurance policy whose face amount decreases each year. When the contract is annuitized, the term life insurance expires, and the annuitant begins receiving payments. If the annuitant dies before the annuity period, then his beneficiary receives the death benefit from the term insurance and the value of the annuity, distributed according to the settlement option chosen.
These fixed annuities offer a guaranteed minimum interest rate and a guarantee against loss of principal if held to term, though charges may apply if surrendered early. The interest rate is linked to an index, such as the S&P 500. If the index moves upward, the interest rate increases by some percentage of it. If it moves down, then the guaranteed interest rate is paid. The percentage of the investment returns passed on to the annuitant is called the participation rate. However, most annuity contracts cap the participation rate.
However, many insurance companies only guarantee 90% of the premiums paid, plus at least 3% interest. Therefore, if no index-linked interest is earned, because the index declined, then the value of the investment can decline. Also, index-linked interest may be forfeited if the annuity is surrendered early.
Discusses how the index-linked interest rate is computed: Participation Rates, Spread/Margin/Asset Fee, and Interest Rate Caps. It also notes that the method of computation can be changed annually or at the start of the next contract term. Also explains the various indexing methods used to measure the change in an index.
Market-Value Adjusted Annuities
This fixed annuity provides liquidity and growth potential if the contract owner surrenders the contract early. When the contract is surrendered, both a surrender charge and a market value adjustment to the account will be made. If interest rates rise, then the market adjustment will be negative, and vice versa. This is to discourage contract owners from liquidating when interest rates are rising to get a higher rate. The market value adjustment may apply only to the interest if it is not registered, or if it is, then the adjustment may apply to both principal and interest.
Tax Treatment of Annuities
Most payments to annuities are with after-tax dollars. Therefore, the principal is not taxable, but the earnings are when received. The IRS uses the LIFO (Last In, First Out) method to determine what is taxable, which is natural for the IRS because it yields the most taxes. If you paid $100,000 into an annuity, and it earns another $100,000 over the years, then $100,000 principal is not taxed, but the income it generated is. If you take out $50,000, the whole amount will be taxed because of the LIFO method of calculation. If $130,000 is withdrawn, then $100,000 of that amount will be taxed; the rest being considered as principal. If applicable, the 10% early withdrawal penalty applies only to what is taxable. If the annuity is used as collateral for a loan, the loan may be taxed just like it was an actual withdrawal. Variable annuity earnings are always taxed as ordinary income by the IRS, never as capital gains, even if some of the earnings are from capital gains.
An annuity contract can be terminated and the money withdrawn, but all earnings will be taxed as ordinary income, and if withdrawn before the contract owner is 59½, then a 10% tax penalty may apply to the earnings.
How Payouts are Taxed
How much of the payouts are taxed is computed by the insurance company and sent to the annuitant as a Form 1099. When the payments are received periodically, certain tax exclusions apply, one which depends on the settlement option chosen (straight life has the largest exclusion), and another exclusion depends on the age and sex of the annuitant — the Treasury Life Expectancy Multiple. That proportion of periodic payments considered taxable are spread out over the life expectancy of the individual rather than using the LIFO method of taxing all income over the cost basis.
Death Benefit Provision
If the contract owner dies during the accumulation period, most contracts provide for a death benefit, where all money deposited and earned will be paid to the contract owner's beneficiary, the earnings of which will be taxed as ordinary income to the beneficiary. No tax penalty will apply even if the annuitant is younger than 59.5. If the variable annuity lost money in its investments, then the beneficiary will receive at least everything that has been paid in by the contract owner.
Tax-Free 1035 Exchanges for Annuities
Section 1035 of the U.S. tax code allows the tax-free exchange, called a 1035 exchange, of an existing variable annuity contract for a new annuity contract, which is often done to obtain a larger death benefit, different annuity payout options, or a wider selection of investment choices. Note that if the contract is surrendered as cash, it will be taxed, even if it is used to buy another annuity.
The disadvantages of exchanging annuities, is that surrender charges on the old annuity may be assessed if still applicable, and a new surrender charge period, which may be as long as 10 years, may begin on the new annuity. Be sure to compare fees and expenses as well as benefits of the annuities before making the exchange.
Investor Alert! Be aware that some commissioned salespeople may try to get you to exchange your current annuity for a new one so that they can earn the commission on the sale. Weigh the benefits and drawbacks of the new annuity carefully, including any extra fees that you'll have to pay because of the exchange. Ask yourself:
- What new features does the new annuity have to offer?
- Is it worth the price, including the fees for the exchange?
- How long will the new surrender period be?
- What are the surrender charges?
- Will I need the money before the new period expires?
Longevity Insurance (12/18/2006)
As people live longer, there is a danger that they will outlive their income. At least 20% of people aged 65 will live at least another 30 years. Longevity insurance is like a single-payment deferred annuity that is typically purchased by the annuitant around retirement age to receive guaranteed monthly payments for the rest of the annuitant's life, starting at around age 80-85. It differs from a deferred annuity in that the payment schedule is determined at the time of purchase, whereas the payouts of a deferred annuity are determined when the payments start, and will vary depending on how well the invested money performed. Thus, one advantage of longevity insurance is that the annuitant knows exactly how much she'll be getting, but the disadvantage is that the payout remains the same even if the markets do well over the years.
The main advantage is the much larger payouts of longevity insurance over a deferred annuity for the same investment — more than 4 times greater — which is possible because most people will die before receiving any payout, leaving more for those who survive. If the annuitant dies before receiving any payments, then the insurance company keeps the money. Another advantage is that since the payout is known, estate planning is easier.
Because only a few insurance companies are offering this coverage — MetLife, Hartford, and the New York Life Insurance Company — costs are high, especially the sales commission, which can be as high as 5%-7%. And although some options can be added, such as a death benefit, inflation protection, or a return of premium, this can greatly increase the cost. Also, the inflation protection doesn't start until the payouts start — inflation until then is not covered.
If You Outlive Your Savings - WSJ.com
Structured Notes — Equity-Indexed Annuities
New financial products — structured products and equity-indexed annuities — are being marketed that promise an investor possible good returns, but no losses.
Structured products and equity-indexed annuities are contractual derivatives that an investor purchases in exchange for returns based on the terms of the contract, which is predicated upon other financial assets or derivatives. (Structured products are sometimes called structured notes, because they are much like bonds or notes — contracts that promise to pay according to the terms of the contract, and have a maturity date, when the investor will get back the principal.)
Structured products are issued by brokerages and trade on the American Stock Exchange. An example of a recently issued note — a type of note called an indexed-linked note — is the Morgan Stanley Capital Protected Notes (GBI);(Prospectus for GBI). This note derives its value from 3 indexes, equally weighted: the Dow Jones Euro Stoxx 50 Index, the Standard & Poor's 500-stock index, and Japan's Nikkei 225. The original issue date was February 28, 2007 for $10 per share, it pays a small dividend, and matures in 2011. These notes are senior unsecured obligations of Morgan Stanley.
A drawback to the notes is that it is difficult to currently ascertain the liquidity of the products.
Equity-indexed annuities are issued by insurance companies and also have a no-loss guarantee, and are based on stock indexes. However, they have severe drawbacks:
- There are annual caps on returns, usually about 7%, so annuities will not do as well over the long term as investing in the stocks or indexes directly.
- No dividends are paid.
- There are penalties for surrendering the annuity early, and this period could be as long as 16 years.
An important caveat for both of these products is that the guaranteed return, like bonds, depends on the financial status of the issuer. If the issuer becomes insolvent, then these financial instruments could become worthless.
Never Lose on Stocks Again -- for a Price